Sami Zayns recent rise in WWE booking has become one of the most debated topics among fans, and now its being openly questioned by two veterans who have lived inside the creative bubble.
During a discussion on The Coach and Bro Show, Vince Russo and Jonathan Coachman spent several minutes breaking down Zayns positioning, his recent wins, and why they believe the push simply does not line up with believable storytelling.
The conversation began after Coachman laid out the current situation on television. Zayn won a Fatal Four-Way in Montreal and is now positioned for a major Royal Rumble match against Drew McIntyre, with WWE clearly leaning into regional and cultural connections to amplify crowd reactions. Coachman questioned whether WWE was booking for reaction rather than logic.
Russo didnt hesitate and made it clear this has been a long-running issue for him. Russo specifically pointed to Zayns previous wins and how they impact credibility with casual viewers.
Coachman backed up Russos philosophy and connected it to how wrestling psychology used to be taught. He also acknowledged the emotional crowd reaction while still questioning the logic behind the booking.
Russo responded bluntly and Later in the show, Russo returned to the topic and made it clear his criticism had nothing to do with Zayn personally.
Then he asked the question at the heart of the controversy.
Coachman admitted he couldnt even force himself into disagreement. He then explained what he believes WWE used to value in presentation.
Coachman even shared a conversation he had earlier in the day. He continued by questioning Zayns presentation.
Russo added his own blunt assessment.
Coachman then gave a visual example that summed up his issue with Zayns positioning next to newer stars.
Russos answer was simple.
Coachman closed the exchange in agreement.
The discussion wasnt framed as personal attacks, but as a creative debate from two people who have spent years behind the scenes. Still, the comments are bound to strike a nerve with fans who are divided over Zayns current positioning near the top of the card. Sami Zayn continues to get strong crowd reactions, but questions about realism, presentation, and long-term credibility arent going away any time soon. Whether WWE adjusts course or doubles down remains to be seen.
Do you agree with Russo and Coachmans criticism of Sami Zayns push, or do you think WWE has it right and fans should just embrace the underdog story? Share your thoughts and let your voice be heard.
Please credit Ringside News if you use the above transcript in your publication.
